The most historically inaccurate movies ever readers digest. Like many historical dramas, pearl harbor provoked debate about the artistic license taken by its producers and director. May 25, 2001 any bigbudget movie about an event as worldchanging and emotionally charged as the attack on pearl harbor is bound to stir concerns about its historical accuracy, portrayal of real individuals and characterizations of various groups. Why do people hate pearl harbor 2001 so much more than anything else. No one goes to watch a michael bay movie expecting historical accuracy. Dec 06, 2018 on december 7, 1941, a military strike by the imperial japanese navy air service hit the united states naval base at pearl harbor in hawaii. Pearl harbour survivors attack movie world news the. Gailey, who has written seven books on the pacific. Jun 06, 2001 is pearl harbor historically accurate. But the chasm between pearl harbor the movie and real pearl.
Conspiracy theories abound regarding the assassination of u. I had to talk to the admiral who was running pearl harbor, all the. I chose this novel because i have particular interest learning about the past wars, and this novel tied in a love story, which gave more reason to. It was geared towards romanticizing the movie by having a love story involved then the actual war. Reviews reel american history films list lehigh university.
Pearl harbor, by randall wallace, is a wellrounded novel that coherently combines the tragedy of war with the greatness of romance. The movie correctly how the us naval command failed to anticipate a japanese aerial assault on pearl harbor. Although it was the most expensive movie ever filmed up to then, critics considered it to be an average film at best and a poor film at worst. This includes the salvage operations we see going on afterwards. Why are other movies this bad historically beloved classics to some people, whereas this movie. The producers of this movie were more focused on the audiences relationship to the characters and the way they felt rather than how accurate. The film presented a heavily fictionalized version of the japanese at tack on pearl harbor on december 7, 1941, focusing.
Top ten differences between pearl harbor real life and movie. Faith hill music video there youll be a trailer for the beyond the movie. Pearl has nice love story, but inaccuracies mar movie. The movie depicted one of the main characters leaving new york for england while the other two gave him a tearful farewell. Crete might be an idyllic tourist island now, but during a 12day period in may 1941 a mixed force of. A latemodel a6m3 zero model 22 in green camouflage used in the film. Dramatic in its nature, pearl harbor is certainly meant to be an artistic retelling of the events of the pearl harbor attack. The endless historical errors made in the pearl harbor movie.
Lee laments not only the films historical inaccuracies but also the false. Though the movie makes it a little easier to swallow that he be blamed for a lack of preparedness. On december 7, 1941, a military strike by the imperial japanese navy air service hit the united states naval base at pearl harbor in hawaii. The film has been directed without grace, vision, or originality, and although you may walk out quoting lines of dialog, it will. The us naval war room lieutenant did tell the admirals how pearl could be the very target but the admirals just brushed it away 2. This film depicts the events leading up to, during, and immediately following the attack. Another major flaw with this movie is that after the attack sequence the movie dragged on for another hour trying to give an epilogue which was totally irrelevant. Pearl harbor detailing some of the ways that the film s final cut didnt reflect all the attacks facts, or represent.
The creative forces behind this film give their viewers an accurate movie, if judged only one the widest of scalesthere was a u. While the b25 mitchell bomber is an easy plane to fly, the participants would have come from qualified bombardment squadrons. Pearl harbor movie everything michael bay got wrong. Instead, the film shows rear admiral raymond spruance as the tactical commander during the battle of midway. These small inaccuracies are sometimes intentional, sometimes careless mistakes, and sometimes used to fill in historical gaps. Although the film used realistic explosions, pearl harbor historians were underwhelmed with the historical accuracy. The movie also shows how the americans became aware of a japanese plot to attack pearl harbor after they had decoded some secret communications. Anger as hollywoods most costly film writes heroes out of history. The ones used in filming were probably either p40ks, p40ms, or p40ns instead of the historically correct p40bs or p40cs that were around at the time of the attack.
While hollywood often takes shortcuts to fit within a twohour runtime, it shouldnt omit or change key moments if the film is intended to come across as a historical piece. Pearl harbor 10 historically inaccurate movies howstuffworks. All the historical inaccuracies in michael bays pearl harbor ranker. Pearl harb or is a 2001 american romanti c war drama f ilm directed by michael bay, produced by bay and jerry bruckheimer and written by randall wallace. If you ever get the chance, i highly recommend going to the uss arizona memorial, but if the only thing you know about pearl harbor is the movie, then let me give you a heads up in advance. Pearl harbor is a 2001 american romantic war drama film directed by michael bay, produced by bay and jerry bruckheimer and written by randall wallace. Despite its name, the movie is not actually about the pearl harbor attacks. In truth, however, the newlyappointed admiral had pointed out the likelihood of a surprise attack on pearl harbor in february of 1941. How historically accurate is the movie tora, tora, tora. They live through the battle before being sent to bomb tokyo. These are among the most obvious, the most historically inaccurate facts featured in this megamotion picture film that present inaccurate. It is normal that pearl harbor would be seen differently from a japanese and an american viewpoint, said chikako inomata, a 19yearold student who watched the movie with a girlfriend. Historical accuracy of michael bays pearl barbor essay.
Jun 08, 2017 why do people hate pearl harbor 2001 so much more than anything else. Michael bays pearl harbor is an example of this as the core characters, played by ben affleck and josh hartnett, were completely made up. Movies like pearl harbor 2001 took many liberties with the events of december 7, 1941, which raises the question of whether or not roland emmerichs 2019 movie based on the battle of midway is equally as lax in its depictions of a major historic event. Nicholas evan sarantakes is the author of keystone. While the b25 mitchell bomber is an easy plane to fly, the participants would have. Pearl harbor 2001 documentary, which can be found on the twodisc 60th anniversary commemorative gift set dvd. National geographic channel produced a documentary called beyond the movie. Movies like pearl harbor 2001 took many liberties with the events of december 7, 1941, which raises the question of whether or not roland emmerichs 2019 movie based. Reality december 7th, 1941, a date which will live in infamy, the united states of america was suddenly and deliberately attacked by naval and air forces of the empire of japan roosevelt. The film contains an armadasized number of errors about the military, including. I reckon if these were taken aboard, then pearl harbor would have been a much better movie and perhaps would not have flopped at. A motley collection of historical details, each of them a bit wrong.
The world war ii battle of midway gets the hollywood treatment in roland emmerichs new movie starring nick jonas and darren criss. Using fictional main characters, pearl harbor 2001 depicts the dramatic japanese attack on the united states that triggered the nations entry into world war ii. The 2001 film pearl harbor was met with a mixed reception at the time of its release. Not only did the movie neglect to provide any real historical context, but the. Not only is the film enormously historically inaccurate, it also fails both as an. May 29, 2001 pearl harbor may be scoring at the box office, but its getting failing grades from historians, who see it as oversimplified and inaccurate. Many pearl harbor survivors dismissed the film as grossly inaccurate and pure hollywood. Pearl harbour survivors attack movie world news the guardian. It stars ben affleck, kate beckinsale, josh hartnett, cuba gooding jr. Rafe and danny are singleengined fighter pilots and would not be qualified to fly multiengined bombers.
Watchmojo top 10 historical inaccuracies in pearl harbor. Sometimes, to beef up the plot of a historical movie, fictional characters are added. After pearl harbor, col doolittle recruited rafe and danny to fly on the raid on tokyo. Japanese aircraft carriers depicted in the movie took advantage of jet catapults. Top 10 biggest historical inaccuracies in pearl harbor. A moving scene except for the fact that it was in a train station. Here are some of the historical inaccuracies in the film pearl harbor. Doc an historical analysis of the movie pearl harbor 2001. The historical inaccuracies of pearl harbor were significant compared to the actual events. The movie follows fictional characters danny and rafe, who are stationed in hawaiis pearl harbor during the attack, seeing them hop into planes to shoot down the enemy fighters. Nov 06, 2019 none of those films are really known for their strict historical accuracy.
Midway is a 2019 american epic war film directed by roland emmerich, who produced the film with harald kloser, and written by wes tooke. Is there a train that runs from new york to england. Pearl harbor movie historical accuracy the movie pearl harbor is based off of the true event of when the japanese attacked hawaiis peal harbor on the island of oahu on december 7th, 1941. None of those films are really known for their strict historical accuracy.
The film, as critics were quick to point out upon its release, is riddled with factual and historical errors. The film does not include vice admiral frank jack fletcher, who was the actual tactical commander in both the battle of the coral sea and the battle of midway. The arizona memorial can be see p 409 pearl habor airplane. Pearl harbor 6 7 which covers some of the ways that the films final cut didnt reflect all the attacks facts, or represent them all accurately8.
The movie romanticizes war and fighting in general for purposes of entertainment, where in reality the attack was violent and a gruesome experience. Pearl harbor, released this summer, will be the most expensive film ever. All the historical inaccuracies in michael bays pearl. Jfk 10 historically inaccurate movies howstuffworks. Pearl harbor is a twohour movie squeezed into three hours, about how on dec. All the historical inaccuracies in michael bays pearl harbor. Why are other movies this bad historically beloved classics to some people, whereas this movie is so easily relegated to the. The film contains an armadasized number of errors about the military, including the wrong planes, nuclearpowered subs before the advent of nuclear power, and magical 21stcentury radio technology. Built for entertainment value, pearl harbor is far from an accurate historical piece. Admiral isoroku yamomoto was not aboard a japanese. However, despite the films box office success, millions of dollars in viewings, and academy award nominations, flaws exist that make it one of the most inaccurate portrayals of a historical event in filmmaking history. One of the most obvious mistakes was the incident shown in the movie when rafe mccauley played by ben affleck is shot down while his service in the uk.
Pearl harbor may be scoring at the box office, but its getting failing grades from historians, who see it as oversimplified and inaccurate. How the movie pearl harbor told its own version of the. The film features an ensemble cast, including ed skrein, patrick wilson, luke evans, aaron eckhart, nick jonas, mandy moore, dennis quaid, tadanobu asano, and woody harrelson. The movie also makes clear that the us believed that its pacific fleet was safe in pearl harbor. The film went for accuracy in nearly every aspect, from faithfully recreating ships and planes that were long out of production to securing script input from naval history and heritage command.
Movies are often romantic in nature, but when the film pearl harbor burst into theaters around the world, viewers received more than an engaging, romanticized take on the terrible events of that december day. The movies version of the attack on pearl harbor is largely accurate. Pearl harbor 2001 movie mistakes, goofs and bloopers. Watchmojo top 10 histoical inaccuracies in pearl harbor. Pearl harbor, released this summer, will be the most expensive. The arizona memorial can be see n oncamera when nurses visit pearl harbor by ferry. Japan surprise attacked the hawaiian naval base, pearl harbor, approximately at. Behind the love story in this film, the historical events that this movie portrays are, for the most part, historically accurate.
283 125 341 1424 1392 213 463 353 350 1568 318 525 1212 960 466 462 868 1592 795 392 628 1506 58 346 1129 227 742 422 173 1267 759 1063 1284 588 1542 872 162 1001 576 113 291 874 664 37 964 1262 525